Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Abigail's avatar

Daniel, I was drawn to the image of the fallen tree bleached and gleaming in the moonlight (though I suppose it could be sunlight too), and then I had to work a little harder for the other images. I was momentarily stuck on the girl tracing a line in the clay as a runaway, so that really threw me off track. The fact that Fortune was capitalized clued me in that these were symbols, so I went back and discovered the girl was the river winding her way through the clough. Then I was off and running again. The idea of winter being the river's womanhood is a bit chilling. Yet not necessarily damning womanhood I suppose since there is a yearly thaw. Does the river become a girl again every spring? I enjoyed the "patois of the tires" as a contrast, making the reader feel more strongly the pull to join the tree, and yet it is a wretched orison because the bare branches are not lifting in praise but scrabbling for purchase on the land. The river represents a loss of self or remembrance. I did not expect this. I first thought of the track the river cuts ever deeper as a kind of lasting tribute to the river and all who observed it. But this is too optimistic. The tree will not join the river willingly but lose its self or its consciousness when it is pulled in, so the anxiety of the title is fulfilled. The alliteration and rich vocabulary work with the strong images, making this one really fun to think through. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Michelle Ma's avatar

This is a spectral and beautiful poem. Its sanctity as a truly sublime poem is haunting. There are a lot of words I don't know. It sounds beautifully and arduously crafted. Great job!

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts